More Pages: Hawaii Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67


Remarkable story, puzzling methodology
Very touching story!
One Word....

Fascinating history, but not enough details.
RE: Forbidden Isle
Excellent book on the forbidden island of Niihau

insight into Japanese plans
Essential primary sourcesOne of the key distinctives of Prange's research and writing was that, unlike so many other writers about the attack, he never forgot the Japanese half of the equation. In fact, the Pearl Harbor attack was a massive tactical undertaking, and the Japanese carried it off brilliantly. Focusing entirely on, for example, how much FDR knew and when, means ignoring the magnitude of the Japanese accomplishment.
Prange never made this mistake. And it's his research and interviews in Japan that produced this important work, assembled and published by his two assistants. While "The Pearl Harbor Papers" may be too esoteric for casual students of the Day of Infamy, people with a more serious interest in the attack, or the Pacific War generally, will find much here to keep themselves occupied.
Of particular interest are several papers and affidavits by Minoru Genda, the key planner of the attack. Also very interesting is "An Intimate Look at the Japanese Navy," by Masataka Chihaya, a former officer of the Imperial Japanese Navy, who shortly after the end of the war cataloged his services' successes and failures. It's a very clear-eyed document, and deserves a close reading.
On the whole, this is a very good book to add to your shelf of Pearl Harbor books (and anyone who has such a shelf unquestionably needs this).
Japan's Plan For Hawaii and Greater East Asia

What an inspiring story!
Hawaii's Own!
For everyone who loves Hawaii

Punia and the King of Sharks
Great adjunct to our Hawaii trip!
A Wonderful Tale

Interesting, but...First of all, the capture of Hawaii would significantly alter US strategy beyond imagination. The war in Europe would be shut down to life support level. In other words, just enough effort to save face, not a nationwide effort.
That would prolong the war in Europe, to say the least. Germany may even end up as the ultimate winner in this scenario.
Second, Americans will not wait until 1945 to recapture the island. They will arrive, as fast as possible. Recapturing Hawaii would be the first priority.
Third, the ending is too unreal to comment. The Hawaiian collaborator "King" would be sent to the mainland, given a mock trial, and imprisoned for life just like Noriega.
Obviously the authors have seen very little world outside Hawaii.
What If Japan had Won?Ziegler and Patterson (myself) have used historical precedent, and plausible alternative scenarios to extend the war in the Pacific for 3 years, and give it a very different final outcome that will surprise even the most jaded reader.
The book is a look at the history of the Second World War from an alternative perspective. It assumes that small changes in major events can alter the course of history. The basis of this assumption is, of course, the historian's axiom: there is no inevitability. The authors begin the book with the sinking of USS Enterprise in the channel to Pearl Harbor, and the destruction of the U.S. Pacific Fleet's oil reserves, thus leaving Hawaii and the Pacific essentially undefendable. Recognizing this (as he did, in reality, 6 months after the attack on Pearl) Admiral Yamamoto Isoroku orders the invasion of the Hawiian Islands - and the Imperial Japanese Army is successful. The key point: how would that have changed the war.
To answer this question, the authors spend time on personal, operational, and theater-wide issues and actions. The politics of the Great Pacific War, the passions of the people involved, and the difficulties of soldiers on both sides of the lines, are explored, always with an eye to history. Everything in this book is based on events that did happen - usually elsewhere in the Pacific - and not on far-fetched scenarios. There is no time travel here, no death rays. Just good old fashioned history applied to a what-if scenario.
It is a great read, and has done well in Hawaii among veterans of WWII, contemporary service-people, and locals of all walks of life. It is a book which will make you think twice about the War in the Pacific, and the roles of the two major players, Japan and the United States.
Pineapples for thoughtThis book gives excellent food for thought (pineapples?) about this different history of the isles. The recollections of three generations of Hawaiian-Japanese, newspaper-like reports and university lectures from the (different) future all together paint a picture that is entirely believable. Since all the events and policies described really happened in Japanese-occupied Asia they are probable too.
It could have happened if Japan had taken the isles. That it probably would not have happened as some reviewers complained is besides the point. History would not have happened as we know it, and Hawaii today would be different too. That is the point this book makes. And since the authors kept the book short and focused (no human interest stories, no steamy love scenes, no heroic/stupid politicians) it is utterly enjoyable. Alternative history at its best!


Great ideas for hiking in Kauai
Excellent guide to the "must do" adventures in Maui!

All You Could Possibly Want To Know About Oahu's Beaches
The local's guide for visitors.

An Enjoyable ReadThe story is told from the eyes of his daughter-in-law Phoenix, wife of his second son Tat-Tung. She has to live in the shadow of her mother-in-law Dai-Kan, the First Wife. Dai-Kan is one of the most puzzling characters, she favors the children and grandchildren of the other wives more than her own. You would expect just the opposite.
From this book I began to understand the complex social dynamics of this type of family, and how their Confucian beliefs held the structure in place. I don't think that polygamous marriages are allowed today in China. I'm curious about how they did away with it since it seemed to be such an embedded part of their culture at the beginning of the 20th century.
The descriptions of Hawaii itself are somewhat lacking. Perhaps the author, who was born in Hawaii, suffers from too much familiarity with the subject. I didn't really get a sense of place from this book.
For those interested in Hawaiin historical fiction I would also recommend The Floating City by Pamela Ball.
A rare and precious picture.Set in pre-war Hawaii, the tale pulls together historic fact and fiction in a seamless, involving way, resisting the postcard or magazine style of popular history. She focuses on the intimate and personal details of her characters and families and renders them breathing, sweating, and lifelike. My only disappointment was that the book ended so quickly.
Hawaii and history enthusiasts will find fine detail in her tale that fill in the gaps of Western accounts. Asian Americans will feel and smell the painful and yet matter of fact pressures on the lives of their parents and grandparents. You will marvel at the strength of character of the early Chinese women and the entrenched families that were the rule of the day. And because her writing resists the sterotype, the polemic, and the popular, it transcends the usual place and era pieces.
This is not Michener. This is Hawaii. I hope she keeps writing.
A fascinating and compelling story

An interesting perspective
Fantastic!
Wonderful!
There are countless themes that are reinforced in this story. His parents, especially the personality of his remarkable father are described rivetingly and memorably.
Lafreniere, Daran's collaborator in this work, describes their method in a prefatory note. "It is not," she writes, "a translation, an oral history, or an autobiography." Lafreniere goes on to write that it is the result of "the interplay of opposites," presumably those of herself and Daran. In my view, this is disconcertingly vague and isn't an adequate discussion of methodology. There was extensive collaboration, (no tape recorder), and the reader deserves a clear description of the method that produced such an amazing account. It's a shortcoming of this otherwise amazing, eye-opening, and soulful story.